Are you wanting to get back into working out, looking to improve your fitness, or working toward a new goal? One question comes up time and time again: should you work with a personal trainer, or is working out alone the better choice? The good news is that there is no single right answer. Some people make excellent progress on their own, while others benefit more from personalized training and expert guidance. It all depends on your experience, your motivation to work out, and your goals. Here are the benefits of each approach to help you make an informed decision.
Working out alone gives you a great deal of flexibility. You choose your schedule, your pace, and the exercises that make up your workout program.
This option may be a good fit if you:
That said, it can sometimes be difficult to know whether you're actually making progress. Over time, some people repeat the same exercises, develop poor habits, or make weightlifting mistakes that slow down their strength training progress.
Contrary to popular belief, personal training is not just for athletes or experienced exercisers. A personal trainer is there to support you with a personalized approach based on your needs, whether you're getting back into working out, improving your technique, or working toward a specific goal.
Personal training can help you:
Your personalized training program evolves as you progress, helping you continue moving toward your goals with confidence.
Whether a personal trainer is worth it depends on your needs.
If you're unsure where to start, need guidance, or want to maximize your efforts, a personal trainer can save you time and help you achieve your fitness goals more efficiently.
At the YMCA, our private trainers take the time to understand your goals and your lifestyle so they can create a personalized training plan that works for you.
Not necessarily.
Many people achieve their fitness goals by working out alone, especially if they already have a solid understanding of fitness and follow a consistent routine.
However, a personalized training program created with the support of a qualified professional can make a real difference. It can help you progress more efficiently, adjust your workout program as your needs change, improve your technique, and prevent weightlifting injuries.
According to the Canadian Society for Exercise Physiology (CSEP), adults should accumulate at least 150 minutes of moderate- to vigorous-intensity physical activity each week, along with muscle-strengthening activities at least twice a week.
No matter which approach you choose, the key is to find a realistic routine that you can maintain over the long term.
Looking for simple training tips to help you move more every day? Read our article, 5 Simple Ways to Move More Every Day.
| Working Out Alone | Training with a Personal Trainer |
|---|---|
| Flexible schedule | Personalized training program tailored to your goals |
| Complete independence | One-on-one coaching and personalized support |
| Well suited for experienced exercisers | Technique supervised by a qualified professional |
| Well suited for experienced exercisers | Regular follow-up and accountability |
| Progress depends on your knowledge and experience | Workout program adjusted based on your results |
For many people, the best solution is to combine both approaches: meet with a personal trainer to build a personalized training program, then complete some workouts independently.
Discover our personal training services and benefit from personalized coaching designed to help you achieve your fitness goals, whatever they may be.
"Every person comes with a different story, different challenges, and different goals. Our role is to meet you where you are and help you move forward with confidence."
— Louis Coreas, Personal Trainer, The YMCAs of Québec
Discover our personal training services
